Hello, Fellow Plugin Enthusiasts! We are back with another WordPress plugin comparison. As of now, dozens of WooCommerce loyalty plugins are available, making it challenging to choose the right one.
Amongst the many established solutions, Points and Rewards for WooCommerce Pro and YITH WooCommerce Reward Points are the two big names for the loyalty category. While both help merchants reward loyal customers and encourage repeat purchases, they take different approaches to loyalty program customization & management, customer engagement, and redemption techniques.
In this WordPress Plugin Comparison, we’ll take an objective look at the best WooCommerce points and rewards plugins, evaluating their features, ease of use, customization options, integrations, pricing, and ideal use cases to help you decide which solution best fits your WooCommerce store.
Table Of Contents
- Overview For WordPress Plugin Comparison
- Detailed WordPress Plugin Comparison
- Which Plugin Offers Better Value?
- Our Take On Points and Rewards for WooCommerce vs YITH WooCommerce Points and Rewards
- Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
(Jump to the section that interests you the most!)
Overview For WordPress Plugin Comparison
“Did you know – Roughly 90% to 93% of companies report achieving a positive return on investment (ROI) from their loyalty programs.”
Choosing the right WooCommerce loyalty points and rewards plugin for your store can significantly impact how effectively it will attract loyal customers and build long-term relationships with them.
While almost all plugins offer a point-based reward system, they differ in loyalty program customization, integrations, and redemption techniques.
In this WordPress Plugin Comparison, we will now take a closer look at two established plugins: Points and Rewards for WooCommerce and YITH WooCommerce Points and Rewards. Although both loyalty plugins share the same core objective, their approaches to loyalty management differ in many ways.
1. Points and Rewards For WooCommerce
As we mentioned before, given the ongoing competition amongst WooCommerce stores, it is important to be unique yet accommodating to your customers. Points and Rewards for WooCommerce is the plugin that will help you achieve this and so much more for your eCommerce store.
Consider this plugin to be a bridge. It helps businesses cross the sea of competition to meet their customers and convert them into loyal customers.
How?
When merchants set up points and rewards systems, it creates reward points for customers. Our reward plugin helps merchants create a Point-based loyalty program that lets customers earn and redeem store credit as points.
Store owners can get full access to features such as daily login points, birthday rewards, point log reports, membership benefits, and more!
2. YITH WooCommerce Points And Rewards
YITH WooCommerce Points and Rewards is easy to set up and manage. Admins can reward their customers with points within a few minutes. It helps you with a loyalty program that will power take-out boxes for everyone on board!
It acts as an extension plugin for your WooCommerce that helps to engage customers and motivate them to be loyal to your online store. The WooCommerce rewards plugin is designed to help online store owners implement a points-based loyalty program on their WordPress-powered eCommerce websites.
We have just reached the brink of the WordPress plugin comparison battlefield — time to see which plugin truly delivers.
Detailed WordPress Plugin Comparison
Welcome to the final round of the WordPress Plugin Comparison for Points and Rewards for WooCommerce VS YITH WooCommerce Reward Points. In this section, we will compare the powerful features of both plugins.
The objective? So you can find the best fit for your store’s booking needs. Let’s dig deeper, shall we?
1. Ease of Setup & User Experience
A loyalty program should be easy to customize, launch, and manage without adding to the existing complexities of your WooCommerce store. In this WordPress plugin comparison, we will see which plugin aces in this category.
Both Points and Rewards for WooCommerce and YITH WooCommerce Points and Rewards have a dedicated admin dashboard, extensive documentation, and helpful demos. However, they differ in how they organize their features and guide store owners through setup.
-
Dashboard & Settings Organization
Both plugins have centralized their loyalty settings within WooCommerce, allowing store owners to configure point earning, redemption, customization, customer rewards, and general program settings from a single location.
Points and Rewards for WooCommerce organizes its settings into dedicated tabs like General Settings, Assign Product Points, Membership, Gamification, Campaigns, Notifications, API Settings, and Compatibility. This structure helps WooCommerce store owners quickly locate specific features and keeps the interface organized as additional functionality is enabled.
YITH WooCommerce Points and Rewards, on the other hand, follows a workflow-oriented approach by grouping settings around loyalty management. Store owners can configure earning rules, redemption settings, customer levels, badges, promotional banners, and customer point management from dedicated sections. The interface prioritizes detailed reward configuration over feature categorization, making it well-suited for stores with more complex loyalty requirements.
-
Initial Setup & Configuration
Both Loyalty plugins are relatively straightforward to install and activate. Once enabled, merchants can immediately begin configuring basic point earning and redemption settings.
The difference between the two plugins grows noticeable as the loyalty program grows. Points and Rewards for WooCommerce also offers advanced functionalities like Gamification, API Settings, SMS and Email notifications, Customer ranks, and engaging campaigns.
On the other hand, YITH WooCommerce Points and Rewards keeps most loyalty-related configurations within its primary settings, giving merchants direct access to detailed earning and redemption rules from the beginning.
2. Points Earning Options
| Feature | Points and Rewards for WooCommerce | YITH Points and Rewards |
|---|---|---|
| Purchase Rewards | Award points on product purchases, cart totals, and category-based orders | Purchase-based point rewards |
| Registration Rewards | Reward customers for creating an account | Registration rewards available |
| Referral Rewards | Reward both the referrer and the referred customer | Referral rewards available |
| Birthday Rewards | Automated birthday point rewards | Birthday rewards available |
| Daily Login Rewards | Points for daily store visits and login streaks | Daily login rewards available |
| Product Review Rewards | Reward customers for verified product reviews | Review-based rewards available |
| Product & Category Rewards | Custom point values for specific products and categories | Product/category rules available |
| User Role Rewards | Role-based point earning rules | Role-based rules available |
| First Order Rewards | Dedicated first-purchase reward system | No dedicated first-order reward feature |
| Product Comment Rewards | Reward customers for product comments and discussions | Not available as a dedicated earning method |
| Payment Method Rewards | Award points for selected payment gateways | Not available as a dedicated earning method |
| Social Sharing Rewards | Reward customers for sharing products or store content | Not available as a built-in earning method |
| Subscription Purchase Rewards | Points for subscription-based purchases and renewals | Available through subscription integration |
-
Purchase Rewards
In WordPress Plugin Comparison, both reward customers for purchases, allowing merchants to build a standard points-based loyalty program. Points and Rewards for WooCommerce lets you award points based on products, categories, and cart totals, while YITH WooCommerce Points and Rewards also supports purchase rewards with configurable earning rules.
-
Registration Rewards
Both plugins allow store owners to reward customers for creating an account. Points and Rewards for WooCommerce automatically awards welcome points upon registration, while YITH WooCommerce Points and Rewards offers a similar registration reward to encourage new customer sign-ups.
-
Referral Rewards
Both plugins include referral rewards, enabling merchants to encourage word-of-mouth marketing. Points and Rewards for WooCommerce rewards both the referrer and the referred customer, whereas YITH WooCommerce Points and Rewards supports referral incentives as part of its loyalty system.
-
Birthday Rewards
Both plugins let merchants reward customers on their birthdays to create a more personalized loyalty experience. Birthday points can be configured to encourage repeat visits and strengthen long-term customer relationships.
-
Daily Login Rewards
Both plugins reward customers for logging into their accounts regularly. Points and Rewards for WooCommerce uses daily login rewards to encourage consistent store visits, while YITH WooCommerce Points and Rewards offers a similar incentive to promote recurring engagement.
-
Product Review Rewards
Both plugins reward customers for submitting product reviews, encouraging valuable user-generated content. This helps merchants increase customer engagement while building trust through authentic product feedback.
-
Product & Category Rewards
Both plugins allow store owners to assign different point values to specific products and categories. This makes it easier to promote selected products, seasonal collections, or high-margin items through targeted reward campaigns.
-
User Role Rewards
Both plugins support role-based reward rules, allowing merchants to offer different earning opportunities for different customer groups. This is useful for creating personalized loyalty programs based on user roles.
-
First Order Rewards
Points and Rewards for WooCommerce includes a dedicated first-order reward feature, helping merchants encourage first-time buyers to return for future purchases. YITH WooCommerce Points and Rewards does not currently offer a separate built-in reward specifically for first orders.
-
Product Comment Rewards
Points and Rewards for WooCommerce rewards customers for posting product comments, encouraging additional interaction beyond purchases and reviews. This earning method is not available as a dedicated built-in feature in YITH WooCommerce Points and Rewards.
-
Payment Method Rewards
With Points and Rewards for WooCommerce, merchants can award points when customers choose specific payment methods, making it useful for promoting preferred payment gateways. This functionality is not offered as a dedicated earning option in YITH WooCommerce Points and Rewards.
-
Social Sharing Rewards
Points and Rewards for WooCommerce rewards customers for sharing products or store content on social platforms, helping increase brand visibility and customer engagement. YITH WooCommerce Points and Rewards does not include social sharing rewards as a built-in earning method.
-
Subscription Purchase Rewards
Both plugins can reward subscription purchases. Points and Rewards for WooCommerce offers dedicated support for subscription-based rewards, while YITH WooCommerce Points and Rewards provides this capability through integration with compatible subscription plugins.
3. Reward Redemption & Point Management
A loyalty program isn’t just about allowing your customers to earn points. The main priority of running a successful loyalty program is to provide ample opportunities for reward redemption for your customers. For the WordPress plugin Comparison, we will now check how Points and Rewards for WooCommerce and YITH WooCommerce Points and Rewards handle Reward Redemption and Point Management.
| Feature | Points and Rewards for WooCommerce | YITH Points and Rewards |
|---|---|---|
| Checkout Redemption | Redeem points directly during checkout | Redeem points at checkout |
| Point-to-Discount Conversion | Flexible point conversion settings | Configurable conversion rates |
| Minimum Redemption Threshold | Set minimum points required for redemption | Set minimum redemption thresholds |
| Maximum Redemption Limits | Limit maximum points redeemed per order | Configure maximum redeemable points |
| Point Expiration | Set point validity and expiration periods | Configure point expiration |
| Product & Category Restrictions | Restrict redemption for selected products/categories | Exclude products and categories from redemption |
| Purchase Using Points | Allow purchases using reward points | Discount-based redemption only |
| Manual Point Adjustment | Add or deduct customer points manually | Manual point management |
| Customer Point History | Detailed points transaction history | Customer point history |
| Import & Export Points | Import and export customer reward points | No dedicated import/export tool |
| Point Sharing | Share reward points between users | Not available |
-
Checkout Redemption
Both Loyalty plugins allow customers to redeem their accumulated points during checkout, making it easy to apply rewards before completing a purchase. Merchants can configure how reward points are converted into discounts based on their loyalty program.
-
Point-to-Discount Conversion
Both plugins allow merchants to define custom point conversion rates, giving them control over the value of each reward point. This helps businesses balance customer incentives with overall profitability.
-
Minimum & Maximum Redemption Limits
Both plugins let merchants define minimum and maximum redemption thresholds. These settings help prevent excessive point usage while encouraging customers to accumulate more rewards before redeeming them.
-
Point Expiration
Both plugins support point expiration, allowing merchants to set validity periods for earned rewards. The expiration of unused points can encourage customers to return and make repeat purchases before their rewards expire.
-
Product & Category Restrictions
Both plugins allow store owners to control where reward points can be redeemed by applying restrictions to specific products or product categories. This gives store owners greater flexibility when running promotions or protecting low-margin products.
-
Purchase Using Reward Points
Points and Rewards for WooCommerce allows merchants to let customers purchase eligible products using their accumulated reward points, providing greater redemption flexibility. YITH WooCommerce Points and Rewards, on the other hand, primarily follows a discount-based redemption model, where points are converted into discounts rather than acting as a standalone payment method.
-
Manual Point Management
Both plugins allow merchants to add or deduct points from customer accounts. This is useful for customer support, promotional campaigns, or correcting reward balances. Points and Rewards for WooCommerce allows merchants to import/export the points log and Assign Points On Previous Orders.
-
Customer Point History
Both plugins maintain a record of customer point logs, enabling merchants and customers to track earned, redeemed, and remaining reward points for greater transparency.
-
Point Sharing
Points and Rewards for WooCommerce allows customers to share reward points with other users, adding flexibility to the loyalty program and creating additional engagement opportunities. This functionality is not available as a built-in feature in YITH WooCommerce Points and Rewards.
4. Engagement & Gamification
A modern loyalty program goes beyond earning and redeeming rewards. It requires keeping customers engaged through interactive shopping experiences that encourage repeated purchases. In this WordPress Plugin comparison, we will explore how both plugins tackle keeping customers hooked and which plugin does it better.
Let’s find out …
| Feature | Points and Rewards for WooCommerce | YITH Points and Rewards |
|---|---|---|
| Customer Ranks/Levels | Customer Ranks | Customer Levels |
| Membership Programs | Built-in membership feature with exclusive rewards and benefits | Available through YITH WooCommerce Membership integration |
| User Badges | Achievement badges | Level badges |
| Gamification | Dedicated gamification features to make earning rewards more interactive | Gamification through customer levels and badges |
| Campaigning | Run loyalty campaigns with Spin-the-Wheel, quizzes, referrals, birthdays, comments, social sharing, pop-ups, and festive templates | No dedicated campaigning feature |
| Referral Engagement | Built-in referral rewards | Referral rewards |
| Progress Tracking | Customer rank & point tracking | Customer level & point tracking |
| Reward Notifications | Email notifications for earned rewards | Reward notifications |
| Notifications (Email, SMS & WhatsApp) | Email, SMS & WhatsApp notifications for reward activities | Email notifications |
-
Customer Ranks & Levels
Both plugins encourage repeat purchases by recognizing loyal customers as they earn more points. This progression system motivates customers to continue shopping to unlock new milestones.
Points and Rewards for WooCommerce uses Customer Ranks. Merchants can assign extra points to reward the top-ranked customer (every week or every month). They can set the frequency as per their preference. YITH WooCommerce Points and Rewards offers a similar progression through Customer Levels, enabling businesses to segment and reward customers based on their accumulated points.
-
Membership Programs
Membership programs are a great way to reward loyal customers with exclusive benefits while encouraging repeat purchases. They help businesses create a sense of exclusivity and strengthen long-term customer relationships.
Points and Rewards for WooCommerce comes with a built-in Membership feature that allows merchants to create multiple membership tiers, specify the number of points to join, and set discounts and expiration dates. They can also award different WooCommerce loyalty points to the customers based on their membership tier, while displaying a unique message showcasing the next membership level that the customers can achieve. They can easily include per-currency points ( set the conversion for the points you want to offer on the set order value) for different members’ tiers.
YITH WooCommerce Points and Rewards, on the other hand, does not include a dedicated membership system within the plugin. Merchants who want to offer membership-based benefits can integrate it with YITH WooCommerce Membership, allowing loyalty rewards and memberships to work together within the YITH ecosystem.
-
User Badges
Both Reward plugins include badges to recognize customer achievements and loyalty milestones. These visual indicators help create a sense of accomplishment and encourage customers to remain active in the rewards program.
While both plugins offer this functionality, Points and Rewards for WooCommerce emphasizes user badges as part of a broader engagement strategy alongside customer ranks and gamification features. Merchants also have full control over their position and level names and can show the accumulated points.
-
Loyalty Campaigns
This is one of the biggest differences between the two plugins.
Points and Rewards for WooCommerce includes a dedicated Loyalty Campaign feature that allows merchants to launch interactive campaigns directly from their WooCommerce store. Businesses can create Spin-the-Wheel campaigns, referral campaigns, quiz-based rewards, birthday campaigns, comment-based rewards, and social sharing campaigns using customizable pop-ups. Merchants can also choose from 5+ festive campaign templates, customize campaign visuals, select display pages, track referrals, and automatically notify customers about the points they’ve earned.
YITH WooCommerce Points and Rewards does not provide a built-in campaign management system. While merchants can configure loyalty rules and promotional rewards, interactive campaign experiences such as quizzes, spin-the-wheel rewards, social sharing incentives, and campaign pop-ups are not available within the plugin itself.
-
Referral Engagement
Both plugins include referral rewards, allowing merchants to encourage existing customers to invite new shoppers and grow their customer base through word-of-mouth marketing.
Points and Rewards for WooCommerce integrates referrals into its broader gamified campaign system, enabling merchants to combine referral rewards with promotional campaigns for increased participation. YITH WooCommerce Points and Rewards offers referral rewards as part of its basic loyalty program.
-
Progress Tracking & Reward Notifications
Both plugins allow customers to monitor their loyalty progress by displaying earned points and reward status. They also notify customers about reward-related activities, helping keep users informed and encouraging continued participation.
Points and Rewards for WooCommerce additionally highlights customer ranks and sends notifications for campaign-earned points, creating a more interactive experience throughout the customer journey.
-
Notifications via Email, SMS & WhatsApp
Keeping customers informed about their reward activity not only encourages them to stay engaged with your loyalty program but also with purchases. Both plugins notify customers about important reward updates, but the channels they support differ.
Points and Rewards for WooCommerce allows merchants to send Email, SMS, and WhatsApp notifications for reward-related activities such as earned points, redeemed rewards, and loyalty updates. By supporting multiple channels, store owners can reach customers on their preferred platforms and increase the visibility of their loyalty program.
YITH WooCommerce Points and Rewards primarily relies on email notifications to keep customers informed about their reward points and loyalty activities. While this covers essential communication needs, it doesn’t provide built-in SMS or WhatsApp messaging.
5. Integrations & Compatibility
This might be the final category of WordPress Plugin Comparison, but it’s one of the most crucial. Any loyalty plugin should work smoothly with other plugins of the ecosystem to offer a cohesive and flexible experience for both store owners who are creating loyalty programs and customers who are interacting with it.
Let us see which of the two plugins offers more integrations and compatibility –
| Feature | Points and Rewards for WooCommerce | YITH WooCommerce Points and Rewards |
|---|---|---|
| Membership Compatibility | Built-in Membership feature + Membership for WooCommerce compatibility | Integrates with YITH WooCommerce Membership |
| Subscription Compatibility | Compatible with WooCommerce Subscriptions and Subscriptions for WooCommerce | Compatible with YITH WooCommerce Subscription |
| Email Marketing | Klaviyo and Mailchimp integration | No dedicated email marketing integrations |
| Multi-Vendor Marketplace | Compatible with Dokan Marketplace and MultiVendorX | Works primarily within the YITH ecosystem |
| Wallet Integration | Wallet System for WooCommerce compatibility | No dedicated wallet integration |
| Gift Card Compatibility | Compatible with Gift Cards for WooCommerce | No dedicated gift card integration |
| Currency Support | Currency Switcher for WooCommerce compatibility | Multi-currency support through compatible solutions |
| Page Builders | Elementor and Gutenberg compatibility | Standard WooCommerce compatibility |
| Payment Compatibility | WooCommerce PayPal Payments compatibility | WooCommerce payment compatibility |
| WPML Support | WPML compatible | WPML compatible |
| Developer Support | REST API for custom integrations | No dedicated public API |
-
Membership & Subscription Compatibility
Both plugins can be used alongside membership and subscription-based stores.
Points and Rewards for WooCommerce includes a built-in Membership feature and is compatible with both WooCommerce Subscriptions and Subscriptions for WooCommerce, allowing merchants to reward customers for subscription purchases and renewals.
YITH WooCommerce Points and Rewards integrates with YITH WooCommerce Membership and YITH WooCommerce Subscription, making it a suitable option for merchants already using the YITH ecosystem.
-
Marketing & Customer Engagement Integrations
Points and Rewards for WooCommerce integrates with Klaviyo and Mailchimp, enabling merchants to sync customer reward data with their email marketing platform and create personalized loyalty campaigns.
YITH WooCommerce Points and Rewards focuses primarily on loyalty management and ecosystem integrations rather than native email marketing platform connections.
-
Marketplace & WooCommerce Extensions
For marketplace businesses, Points and Rewards for WooCommerce offers compatibility with Dokan Marketplace and MultiVendorX, allowing vendors to participate in store-wide loyalty programs.
The plugin also integrates with Wallet System for WooCommerce, Gift Cards for WooCommerce, Currency Switcher for WooCommerce, and WooCommerce PayPal Payments, extending the functionality of the loyalty program across multiple WooCommerce extensions.
YITH WooCommerce Points and Rewards provides strong compatibility with other YITH plugins, making it a natural fit for stores already built around the YITH ecosystem.
-
Website & Developer Compatibility
Both plugins support WPML, allowing merchants to run multilingual loyalty programs.
Points and Rewards for WooCommerce also offers compatibility with Elementor, Gutenberg, and includes a REST API for custom integrations, giving developers additional flexibility when extending the loyalty program or connecting it with external applications.
Which Plugin Offers Better Value?
While we are running a WordPress Plugin Comparison, this is another essential factor. But again, price alone can not help you get the whole story.
We will surely compare the pricing models, but here is what you get for what you pay…
1. YITH WooCommerce Points and Rewards
YITH WooCommerce Points and Rewards is priced at $139.99/year for a single-site license. For businesses already using the YITH ecosystem, the pricing may be justified by its seamless integration with other YITH extensions.
However, merchants comparing standalone loyalty solutions may also want to evaluate the built-in features offered at this price point before making a decision.
2. Points and Rewards for WooCommerce
WP Swings offers more flexible pricing options and includes a feature-rich free version:
- Free Version: Available on Points and Rewards for WooCommerce
- 1 Site License: $99/year
- 5 Site License: $199/year
- 10 Site License: $409/year
With the paid version, store owners can unlock advanced features like multi-level memberships, API settings, gamification, and user levels.
Our Take On Points and Rewards for WooCommerce vs YITH WooCommerce Points and Rewards
The right choice ultimately depends on which of the two aligns with your business goals, existing plugin ecosystem, and the type of loyalty experience you want your customers to experience.
If your priority is a structured, rule-driven rewards program with deep integration into YITH’s ecosystem, YITH WooCommerce Points and Rewards is a reliable choice. Its configurable earning and redemption rules, customer levels, and seamless compatibility with other YITH extensions make it well suited for merchants already invested in their product suite.
On the other hand, if you’re looking for a more comprehensive WooCommerce points and rewards solution that combines points and rewards with membership benefits, gamification, campaign management, customer engagement tools, and broader third-party integrations, Points and Rewards for WooCommerce offers a more feature-rich experience within a single plugin. Features such as Gamified Loyalty Campaigns, Customer Ranks, Membership, WhatsApp/SMS notifications, and various marketing integrations enable merchants to build a loyalty program that goes beyond earning and redeeming points.
Rather than asking which plugin is objectively “better,” it’s more useful to consider which one aligns with your store’s customer retention strategy. If your focus is on creating a traditional loyalty program with advanced rule configuration, YITH is a solid option. If your goal is to deliver a more engaging, interactive, and scalable customer loyalty experience while minimizing the need for additional extensions, Points and Rewards for WooCommerce is well worth considering.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. What is the main difference between WooCommerce Points and Rewards and YITH WooCommerce Points and Rewards?
The main difference between WooCommerce Points and Rewards and YITH WooCommerce Points and Rewards is that while both help merchants reward loyal customers and encourage repeat purchases, they take different approaches to loyalty program customization & management, customer engagement, and redemption.
2. Is there a free version available for either plugin?
YITH WooCommerce Points and Rewards doesn’t have a free version, and the premium version starts from $139.99/year for a single-site license. On the other hand, Points and Rewards for WooCommerce has a free version listed on WordPress.
3. Can customers earn points for actions other than making a purchase (e.g., reviews or registrations)?
Yes, Points and Rewards for WooCommerce allows customers to earn rewards for submitting product reviews and for creating an account; this encourages valuable user-generated content and new account sign-ups.
4. Do both plugins allow store owners to set expiration dates for points?
Yes, both Points and Rewards for WooCommerce and YITH WooCommerce Points and Rewards support point expiration, allowing merchants to set validity periods for earned rewards. The expiration of unused points can encourage customers to return and make repeat purchases before their rewards expire.
5. Which plugin offers better options for creating tiered or level-based loyalty programs?
Points and Rewards for WooCommerce comes with a built-in Membership feature that allows merchants to create multiple membership tiers, specify the number of points to join, and set discounts and expiration dates. YITH WooCommerce Points and Rewards, on the other hand, does not include a dedicated membership system. Merchants who want to offer membership-based benefits can integrate it with YITH WooCommerce Membership.
About the Author: Muskaan Sabarwal
